Topic 3Analytic Rubric Domains

Development and Support

Top ACT essays do more than state opinions. They prove them with concrete support and follow the reasoning through.

Core Idea

Development and Support asks whether each claim is earned. Strong essays give specific evidence, explain why it matters, and follow the argument through to its consequences.

Understanding

Read this domain as a paragraph-quality check. A scorer is asking whether each claim is actually earned on the page or whether the writer stopped at opinion.

  • What earns points: a concrete example, a sentence that explains why that example matters, and a clear sense of what follows from the claim.
  • What weakens scores: broad assertions, dropped-in evidence with no commentary, or a paragraph that piles up examples without proving one idea clearly.
  • Revision move: in each body paragraph, label the sentences claim, evidence, and commentary. If you can find evidence but not commentary, the paragraph is probably underdeveloped.
Question

Worked Example

A student argues that high schools should require financial literacy. Which body-paragraph move would most strengthen the essay in the Development and Support domain?

Select an answer to see the explanation